Few things are more frustrating than a screw snapping off in metal just when you think the job’s almost done. Whether you’re fixing furniture, working on your car, or tackling a DIY project, a broken screw can bring everything to a halt.
Knowing how to remove broken screws safely protects your materials—and your sanity. This article walks you through essential tools, step-by-step instructions, and helpful tips so you’ll be ready next time a stubborn screw breaks.
Related Video
How to Remove Broken Screws from Metal: A Complete Guide
When a screw breaks off in metal, it can seem like an impossible problem. But with the right approach, you can extract even the most stubborn broken screws. Whether you’re restoring vintage machinery, fixing furniture, or tackling a home renovation, knowing how to remove broken screws from metal will save you time, money, and frustration.
Let’s walk step-by-step through practical methods and best practices to get broken screws out efficiently and safely.
Understanding Broken Screws: What Makes Them Tough to Remove?
A screw can break for several reasons—overtightening, corrosion, fatigue, or using the wrong tool. When metal is involved, the challenge increases because metal surfaces grip fasteners tightly.
The main obstacles include:
- Lack of gripping surface: When a screw head snaps off, your screwdriver or bit has nothing to bite into.
- Corrosion: Rust bonds metal parts together, locking the screw in place.
- Stripped threads: Threads may be mangled, making traditional removal tough.
But don’t worry! Several methods can help.
Step-by-Step Methods to Remove a Broken Screw from Metal
Below are the most effective techniques, listed from the simplest (and least destructive) to more advanced methods. Start at the top and work through each approach as needed.
1. Using Pliers or Vise-Grips
Best for: Screws with some shaft still protruding
- Grip the protruding screw firmly with locking pliers or vise-grip pliers.
- Twist counterclockwise carefully to unscrew.
- Apply gentle pressure; avoid snapping off more of the screw.
Tip: For extra grip, use pliers with serrated jaws and apply a drop of penetrating oil.
2. Drilling a New Slot
Best for: Screws broken nearly flush but not recessed
- Select a rotary tool (like a Dremel) with a thin cutting disk.
- Cut a notch across the surface of the screw, deep enough to fit a flat-head screwdriver.
- Insert a screwdriver and apply pressure while turning counterclockwise.
This method allows you to gain purchase on otherwise headless screws.
3. Applying Penetrating Oil
Best for: Rusted or seized screws
- Apply penetrating oil (such as WD-40) liberally around the screw.
- Wait 10-15 minutes for the oil to seep into threads.
- Try to remove using pliers or slot method.
Tip: Tap the area gently with a hammer to help the oil penetrate deeper.
4. Using a Screw Extractor (Easy-Out Tool)
Best for: Screws broken off below the surface or with stripped heads
- Drill a pilot hole directly in the center of the broken screw. Use a bit slightly smaller than the screw.
- Insert the extractor tool into the hole.
- Turn the extractor counterclockwise. Its reverse-threaded design will grip the inside of the screw and back it out.
- Apply constant, firm pressure. If it doesn’t budge, stop to avoid breaking the extractor itself.
Pro Tip: Extractor kits are widely available and come in various sizes.
5. Drilling Out the Screw
Best for: Severely stuck screws where other methods have failed
- Select a drill bit slightly smaller than the screw’s diameter.
- Drill slowly and steadily into the center of the screw until it loosens or clears out.
- Remove any remaining fragments with needle-nose pliers or tweezers.
Caution: Take care not to widen or damage the threaded hole. Work slowly!
6. Welding a Nut to the Broken Shaft
Best for: Strongly embedded screws, and when welding equipment is available
- Center a matching nut over the broken screw.
- Weld the nut securely onto the screw stub.
- Allow the weld to cool.
- Use a socket or wrench to unscrew the entire assembly.
This technique is highly effective for larger screws or bolts.
7. Using a Hammer to Loosen the Screw
Best for: Screws held by corrosion or those set with thread lock
- Place a punch or small chisel directly into the center of the broken screw.
- Tap gently with a hammer to break the corrosion seal.
- Try rotating the screw with pliers or an extractor.
8. Applying Heat
Best for: Screws seized due to rust or thread-lock compound
- Use a soldering iron, heat gun, or propane torch to heat the screw area (avoid overheating!).
- The metal will expand, often loosening the screw’s grip.
- Try removing it while still warm, using other methods as needed.
Practical Tips and Best Practices
Removing broken screws isn’t just about the technique; preparation and patience make a difference.
- Work slowly: Rushing can damage threads, making future repairs harder.
- Use the right size tools: Matching the correct extractor or drill bit minimizes further breakage.
- Center your pilot holes: Especially when drilling out or using extractors. A center punch helps keep the bit in place.
- Protect your surface: Place tape around the screw area to prevent scratches or accidental slips.
- Stay safe: Always use goggles and gloves when working with metal and power tools.
Troubleshooting: What If It Won’t Budge?
Occasionally, even with every trick, some screws seem immovable. Don’t despair—here’s what to try next:
- Alternate Heat and Cold: Expand with heat, then contract quickly with cold spray. This can break the bond.
- Soak with penetrating oil longer: Sometimes overnight soaking is necessary for deeply seized screws.
- Check for reverse threads: Rare but possible, especially with specialized machinery.
- Seek professional help: Metal shops have advanced extraction tools and techniques for worst-case scenarios.
When to Replace or Repair Threads
After extracting a broken screw, inspect the hole:
- If threads look clean: You can install a new screw of the same size.
- If threads are damaged: Use a tap to repair threads, or install a threaded insert (like a Helicoil) for a long-term fix.
Cost Tips for Broken Screw Removal
While most broken screw removals can be done with basic tools you already have, here are some ways to keep costs down:
- Buy a basic screw extractor kit: These are affordable and reusable—a smart investment if you tackle projects frequently.
- Borrow tools from friends or neighbors: Extractors, rotary tools, and even welding equipment are often available in community tool libraries.
- Shop local: Avoid shipping fees by checking nearby hardware or auto parts stores for any specialty tools needed.
- Consider repair over replacement: Removing a stuck screw is almost always cheaper than replacing an entire part.
Summary
Removing broken screws from metal may seem intimidating, but armed with the right techniques and a bit of patience, you can conquer even the most stubborn cases. From simple hand tools like pliers and penetrating oil to specialized screw extractors and even advanced methods like welding, there’s a solution for every situation. Take your time, work methodically, and remember: persistence pays off.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What if the broken screw is completely flush or below the metal surface?
You can use a center punch to make a dimple in the center of the screw, then drill a small pilot hole. Insert a screw extractor into the hole and back the screw out. Some extractor kits are designed specifically for deeply embedded screws.
2. Is it possible to remove a broken screw without a screw extractor?
Yes, several methods can work. Try gripping what’s left with pliers, creating a slot with a rotary tool for a flat-head screwdriver, or drilling out the center. Each case is different, so start with the least destructive method.
3. How do I avoid breaking screws in the future?
- Use the correct size and type of screwdriver or bit.
- Avoid over-tightening.
- Apply anti-seize or a drop of oil to screws before installation, especially in metal.
- Pre-drill pilot holes where needed.
- Regularly inspect and replace worn tools.
4. Can I reuse the same hole after removing a broken screw?
Often, yes. If the threads are undamaged, simply install a new screw. If threads are stripped, you may need to use a tap to re-thread the hole or install a threaded insert. Always clean out debris before inserting a new screw.
5. What should I do if the screw extractor breaks inside the screw?
Extractor bits are very hard and can be difficult to drill out. Use a carbide drill bit (specifically designed for hardened steel) to try and remove the broken extractor. If that’s unsuccessful, professional tool shops have specialized removal tools.
Follow these instructions, and you’ll be ready to tackle broken screws like a pro!